Microgenerators: Off-grid vs Hybrid

Share

X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Email

Microgeneration is where heat and electric energy are generated on a small-scale through stand-alone power systems (or mini grids if it is a small community). Power systems are typically renewable energy sources such as solar, wind and hydro-electric/micro turbines. These microgenerators can either be ‘off-grid’ or a ‘hybrid power-system’. For those looking to install a microgenerator, it is important to know the differences between these systems.

Firstly, an off-grid system is not connected to the National Grid. It relies on the renewable energy source to generate energy, and requires battery storage to store excess energy and provide stability. A charge controller regulates the current which flows through to the battery storage from the renewable energy source. This is critical in ensuring that the battery works at optimal performance as well as protecting the battery from overcharging, and makes sure the whole system is efficient in the short-term as well as the long-term. Battery storage will stop storing energy when it has reached maximum capacity.

Direct current is fed into the batteries; however, household appliances are usually powered by alternating current. An inverter is used to convert direct current to alternating current. This is then connected to the load to complete the circuit. When switching the load between these different sources of power at home, a transfer switch needs to be used to facilitate this. Back-up generators may also be needed as a back-up charging source to recharge the battery. They can also used when the system fails, and the battery needs to be bypassed.

Benefits of off-grid systems:
– Allows you to be independent of the National Grid and generate your own energy. This means that you are more resilient to external shocks experienced by the National Grid such as power outages.
– You receive virtually no power bills.
– You are able to minimise your carbon-footprint.
– You can manage how much energy you consume.

Cons:
– There is a high initial up-front cost when installing the renewable energy source and battery.
– When using battery banks or generators they need regular maintenance and/ or watering, so, these costs need to be factored in.
– There is less power security since if the system does not produce enough energy, there is no other alternative. In winter for example, there may not be enough energy generated and stored to meet demand. Even with back-up systems in place, energy storage and generation are limited by the size of the system put in place
– You must monitor every-day activities and restrict energy consumption where possible to improve energy efficiency.

Hybrid systems are embedded into the National Grid and allow you to power your homes independently when it is seasonally optimal to use renewable energy sources (when it is very windy to power turbines etc), and benefit from energy from the Grid as and when required. Excess energy can be fed into the National Grid, which you might get some money from. This will simultaneously help the National Grid respond to the crests and troughs of consumer demand. Further, when the system is unable to generate electricity, the National Grid will be able to supply your electricity needs. Alternatively, batteries can be used to store the excess energy from renewable energy sources, which can be used to power loads during adverse weather conditions or at night allowing appliances to continue to function. Or when energy tariffs are at their highest to avoid importing energy from the Grid at these peak times. Batteries in these systems can also be charged by the Grid where stored energy needs to be topped up. Batteries in hybrid systems reduce your reliance on the Grid, but the Grid is still there as a back-up option.

The system is similar to an off-grid system, but some extra components are needed to manage its connection to the Grid. After electricity is passed through an inverter (as in an off-grid system) a switchboard is used. A switchboard relays the electricity through several circuits and distributes the electricity from one source to another source. This links the power source to transformers and integrates the system into the Grid from there. Similar to an off-grid system, a transfer switch is needed to switch the load between different sources of power at home. Additionally, electricity meters are further needed to monitor system operations. Fuses and circuit breakers should also be included for safety reasons.

Benefits of a hybrid system:
– A hybrid system means that power flow is continuous, meaning it is power secure.
– It’s compatible with other systems and can be used to power other electric appliances such as electric vehicles etc.
– It is highly efficient.
– Maintenance costs are generally low.

Cons:
– These systems can cost more overall to install and run, especially where you are not already connected to the Grid.
– The controlling process is more complex.
– The number of machines which are connectable are limited.

The majority of microgenerators we see installed in the UK today are hybrid systems. When considering which option to go for, you should ask yourself what are your motivations.

References:
1) http://www.icax.co.uk/on_site_renewable_energy.html (ICAX, n.d.)
2) http://www.windandsun.co.uk/information/solutions/off-grid-solutions/diy-off-grid-systems.aspx#.XuSiGLySmUk (Wind&Sun, n.d.)
3) https://zerohomebills.com/basics-about-pv-off-grid-systems/ (0Bills, n.d.)
4) https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Microgeneration#:~:text=%22Off%2Dgrid%22%20microgenerators%20use,grid%20to%20accommodate%20that%20difference. (Bethel Afework, Microgeneration, 25)
5) https://sinovoltaics.com/learning-center/off-grid/off-grid-solar-system-components/ (Rooij, n.d.)
6) https://energyoptions-wind.com/offgrid/ (Energy Options, 2018)
7) https://www.esolar.co.nz/what-are-the-benefits-of-an-off-the-grid-solar-system/ (Esolar, 2013)
8) https://www.intermtnwindandsolar.com/off-grid-solar-energy-systems-pros-and-cons/#:~:text=Disadvantages%20of%20Off%2DGrid%20Solar%20Energy%20Systems&text=Adding%20a%20battery%20bank%20and,run%20out%20of%20stored%20electricity. (Intermountain wind&solar, 2017)
9) https://www.worldsolar.co.nz/blog/pros-and-cons-of-off-grid-vs-hybrid (world solar, 2018)
10) https://www.ecpowersystems.com/resources/switchboards/the-role-of-an-electric-switchboard-in-power-flow/ (East Coast Power Systems, 2012)
11) https://solartechnologies.com/advantages-disadvantages-hybrid-solar-energy-systems/ (Solar Technologies, 2018)

 

Recommended for you

New: Find out more about NEF's Impact

Discover the difference we're making in National Energy Foundation's latest Impact Report. See how we're creating positive change in energy efficiency and sustainability.

National Energy Foundation
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.