A heat pump is a way of using electricity to heat your home, in an energy-efficient way. In this article, we’ll be looking specifically at high temperature air source heat pumps. We’ll be going through their benefits, disadvantages and costs to find out…
Are they worth it?
What is a high temperature air source heat pump?
First up, a high-temperature air source heat pump (HTASHP) is a type of air source heat pump (ASHP) designed to provide heating at higher temperatures than standard ASHPs.
While conventional ASHPs typically produce hot water at temperatures between 35°C and 55°C (95°F to 131°F), a high-temperature version can deliver water temperatures up to 80°C (176°F) or higher.
How does a high temp air source heat pump work?
Heat Extraction:
They extract heat from the outside air, even in cold weather. They work by absorbing heat from the outside air using a refrigerant, which then evaporates at a low temperature.
Heat Boosting:
What sets HTASHPs apart is their advanced compressor technology and the use of different refrigerants that allow them to boost the temperature of the heat they extract. Some designs use two-stage compression systems or special high-efficiency compressors that can increase the temperature of the refrigerant to higher levels.
Heat Delivery:
The heated refrigerant passes through a heat exchanger, transferring its heat to the water in the system. This water can then be used for space heating, hot water, or both.
What are high temp air source heat pumps used for?
These heat pumps are useful for retrofitting buildings, cold climates and the sinter months.
Let’s take a closer look:
Retrofit in Older Buildings
These heat pumps are particularly useful in retrofitting older buildings that have traditional radiators or underfloor heating systems designed for higher water temperatures.
Advantages over standard air source heat pumps
Unlike standard ASHPs, which might struggle to provide sufficient heat in these systems, HTASHPs can deliver the necessary temperature without requiring extensive modifications.
Cold Climates
They are also particularly useful in colder climates, where maintaining a high indoor temperature is critical during winter months.
Benefits of high temperature air source heat pumps
- Energy Efficiency: HTASHPs are still more energy-efficient than traditional fossil fuel heating systems because they move heat rather than generate it by burning fuel.
- Lower Carbon Footprint: Since they often rely on electricity (which can be sourced from renewable energy), they contribute to reducing carbon emissions, especially when compared to oil or gas heating systems.
- Versatility: They can be integrated into existing heating systems, making them a flexible solution for buildings where full system overhauls are impractical.
Air source heat pumps disadvantages
Air source heat pumps (ASHPs) offer many advantages, particularly in terms of energy efficiency and environmental benefits.
However, they also come with some disadvantages that should be considered before installation.
Here are some of the key drawbacks:
Lower Efficiency in Cold Climates
ASHPs rely on extracting heat from the air, so their efficiency decreases as outdoor temperatures drop.
In very cold climates, their ability to heat effectively can be compromised, sometimes requiring a backup heating system.
In freezing conditions, the outdoor unit may need to defrost regularly, which can reduce efficiency and lead to short bursts of colder air indoors.
These are both among the bigger disadvantages of air source heat pumps.
Higher Upfront Costs
While ASHPs can save money on energy bills over time, the initial cost of purchasing and installing the system is higher than some traditional heating systems, like gas boilers.
Retrofitting an ASHP to an existing home, especially one designed for higher temperature heating systems, may require additional modifications (like upgrading insulation or replacing radiators), which can add to the cost.
They can be noisy
When people list air source heat pump disadvantages, one of the areas they focus on is noise.
The external unit of an ASHP can produce noise during operation, especially when the compressor and fan are running. While modern units are designed to be quieter, the noise might still be an issue in noise-sensitive areas.
Air source heat pumps require space
The outdoor unit can be bulky and may not be aesthetically pleasing. Finding an appropriate location where it won’t be an eyesore or disturb neighbours can be a challenge.
A further air source heat pump disadvantage is that many ASHP systems also require an indoor water storage tank, which takes up space within the property.
Heat pumps disadvantages: Heating Output Limitations
Because they heat to higher temperatures, high-temperature heat pumps use more electricity.
When it comes to air source heat pumps disadvantages, they are more expensive to run than more conventional heat pumps, although cheaper than an electric panel or storage heaters.
The figure of 1:2.5 units of electricity in to heat out is sometimes quoted, although (like all heat pumps) this will vary according to the season.
Installing a weather compensating system is likely to improve efficiencies, by enabling the heat pump to work at its optimum operation for more of the time.
Lower Temperature Output:
Standard ASHPs generally produce lower water temperatures (typically 35°C to 55°C) compared to conventional heating systems like gas or oil boilers. This means they may not be as effective if the home has traditional radiators designed for higher temperatures.
Longer Warm-Up Times:
Because ASHPs operate at lower temperatures, it can take longer to heat up a space compared to traditional systems.
Complex Installation
Proper installation is crucial for efficiency and longevity. The installation process can be complex, requiring a skilled installer who understands the nuances of heat pump systems.
Poor installation can lead to suboptimal performance and higher operating costs. While this might not necessarily be a disadvantage, it does require extra specialist help.
Maintenance Requirements
Another disadvantage is that ASHPs require regular maintenance to ensure they operate efficiently.
This includes cleaning filters, checking refrigerant levels, and servicing the outdoor unit, which can add to long-term costs.
Air source heat pump disadvantages: are they worth it?
While air source heat pumps are a sustainable and energy-efficient heating option, they do come with disadvantages such as reduced efficiency in cold climates, higher upfront costs, noise concerns, and space requirements.
Careful consideration and planning are necessary to ensure that an ASHP is the right choice for a particular property.
Heat temperature heat pumps are also reported to cost about 25% more to buy and install, despite it not being necessary to change radiators etc.
High temperature air source heat pump costs
ASHPs run on electricity, so their carbon footprint and operating costs are tied to the source and price of electricity.
In areas where electricity is expensive or primarily generated from fossil fuels, the cost savings and environmental benefits may be less pronounced.
However, one of the disadvantages is that cost can add up in several areas. Let’s explore these in more detail.
Air source heat pumps costs
The cost of a high-temperature air source heat pump (HTASHP) can vary significantly depending on the size of the system, the complexity of the installation, and the location.
Here’s a breakdown to give you an idea:
Upfront Costs: equipment and installation
The price of a high-temperature air source heat pump can vary based on the brand, capacity (measured in kilowatts, or kW), and features of the unit.
Installation costs can also range, depending on the complexity of the installation, the need for any modifications to the existing heating system, Factors like the location of the outdoor unit, the need for additional piping, or upgrading electrical systems can increase installation costs.
Additional Retrofitting Heat Pump Costs
Retrofitting an high temperature air source heat pump to an existing heating system may require modifications.
For example, older homes with radiators designed for higher temperatures might need upgrades, such as larger radiators or improved insulation, which can add a lot to the overall cost.
Hot Water Cylinder
If the system also needs to provide domestic hot water, you might need a compatible hot water cylinder, which could add another $1,000 to $2,000.
Permits and Inspections
Depending on local regulations, you might need permits or inspections, which could add a few hundred dollars to the cost.
Heat Pump Operating Costs
The operating cost depends on electricity rates in your area. HTASHPs are generally more efficient than traditional heating systems, but their efficiency can vary with outdoor temperatures.
The amount you spend on per year on electricity will depend on the size of your home, climate, and usage.
Regular maintenance is necessary to keep the system running efficiently.
When is a high-temperature heat pump likely to be the best option?
A high-temperature heat pump is likely to be the best option for homes that cannot be insulated to meet current Building Regulations or better.
This might be because they are Listed or in a Conservation Area or homes where the costs and risks of insulation are high – for example homes with uninsulated solid floors, in very exposed places or unusual construction.
High temperature heat pumps for landlords
High-temperature heat pumps may also be a good solution for tenanted properties currently heated using electric panel heaters.
Installing a high-temperature heat pump will be less disruptive for the tenant and require little or no adaptation from them on how to use their new heating system.
Heat pumps and hot water
Another reason is if you need a heat pump that can produce hot water as well as space heating and you don’t have room for a hot water cylinder – our blog ‘Can I get my hot water from an air source heat pump’ has more information on this.
Flow temperatures of low-temperature air source heat pumps
To achieve three or four units of heat for every unit of electricity consumed the temperature of the fluid running through a low-temperature heat pump needs to be lower than that delivered by a conventional boiler.
A low-temperature heat pump runs most efficiently if it is set to run at 35°C to 45°C; in contrast a gas boiler is typically set to run between 60°C to 75°C, although the Government is currently campaigning to get all households to reduce the flow temperature on their boiler to 60°C, to save energy and reduce bills.
Compensating for lower temperatures
To compensate for lower temperatures, three things need to happen; the first of these is to improve the energy efficiency of your home, adopting a fabric-first approach, if this has not already been done.
That means insulation of the floors, walls, floors, and draughtproofing. It may also mean replacing existing windows and doors.
The need for a fabric-first approach is not unique to heat pumps. With high fuel prices, reducing the amount of energy needed to keep your home warm makes sense no matter how your home is heated.
Taking a fabric-first approach also means that your heating system can be sized correctly for the job it needs to do.
The second is to increase the surface area of the heat emitters. This means installing more or larger radiators and/or installing underfloor heating. The third is ensuring that you get a good handover from the installer on how to get the best from your heat pump.
This means keeping the heating on for longer (as lower temperatures mean that your home heats up more slowly) and understanding that the heating system is working as it should although the radiators are no longer hot.
Are high temp air source heat pumps worth it?
Whether a high-temperature air source heat pump (HTASHP) is worth the investment depends on how you see the benefits vs the disadvantages, and several factors specific to your situation.
Older Homes: If you live in an older home with traditional radiators or underfloor heating systems designed for higher temperatures, an HTASHP can be a good fit.
It allows you to upgrade to a more energy-efficient system without the need to replace radiators or make significant modifications to your existing heating infrastructure.
Where you live: climate considerations
If you live in a region with harsh winters, the ability of an HTASHP to provide high-temperature output even in low outdoor temperatures can ensure your home stays warm and comfortable without needing additional heating sources.
Energy Efficiency and Savings
They’re more efficient than traditional oil or gas boilers, potentially leading to significant savings on your energy bills over time, especially if you are switching from a less efficient heating system.
It can also further reduce your carbon footprint and contribute to environmental sustainability.
Upfront Costs vs. Long-Term Benefits
The initial cost of purchasing and installing an HTASHP is higher compared to standard air source heat pumps or traditional boilers. However, the long-term savings on energy bills and potential government incentives can help offset these costs over time.
How long until you see a return on investment?
The payback period depends on energy prices, your existing heating costs, and the efficiency of the system you’re replacing. If you plan to stay in your home long-term, the investment may be worth it as you’ll benefit from ongoing energy savings.
Long term view
When properly maintained, they can have a long lifespan. Regular maintenance ensures continued efficiency and reliability, which can make the system more cost-effective in the long run.
High temperature air source heat pumps Summary
If you are thinking of getting a heat pump installed, you will need to get professional advice on the system that it right for you and your home.
The best place to start is to get a Whole House Retrofit Plan done for your home from a Retrofit Coordinator.
If you would like help to find a Retrofit Coordinator the National Energy Foundation’s SuperHomes Team would be happy to help – you can contact them on superhomes@nef.org.uk or you could search for a Retrofit Coordinator on the TrustMark
If you’re looking for an installer you need to look for one that is certified by the Microgeneration Certification Scheme (MCS). They also have a database of installers who can install air source heat pumps part funded by the Government’s Boiler Upgrade Scheme, which until 2025 should provide £5000 toward the cost of insulation, which is well worth going for.
If the idea of enhancing your home’s energy efficiency through strategic retrofitting and delving into the realm of low-carbon alternatives intrigues you, then our SuperHomes project could be a perfect match. Our community members are at the forefront of redefining sustainable living. For further details, feel free to visit www.superhomes.org.uk