COP26 has ended, but what has been achieved in terms of moving away from the most polluting fossil fuel – coal? How close is the UK to zero reliance on coal-generated power? And do biomass replacements offer a truly sustainable alternative, or do they allow governments to achieve certain goals without implementing real change?
There were 190 signatories to end coal use and de-fund the coal industry at COP26 last month. This included new nations agreeing to switch to renewable energy production, international banks pledging investments in green energy instead of coal, and the world’s most developed states assisting the developing world in their transition to sustainable energy.
Given the huge challenges to the types of multilateral agreements of this size, it is always perceived as a positive when climate summits result in new commitments. This is why The Paris Agreement in 2016 was hailed as such a pivotal moment in the fight against climate change following COP21. But in spite of the initial excitement, the US under Trump withdrew in 2017, highlighting the lack of power and enforcement of this type of deal. So, with these recent coal phase-out pledges being non-binding, there is no guarantee that the agreed targets will be met.
It’s not all so bleak and uncertain. The UK has made major progress in its efforts to eradicate coal from its energy sector. In April 2017, the country had its first coal-free day since the 1800s. This was then eclipsed by a 67-day 22-hour 55-minute period during the Covid pandemic in 2020. A staggering accomplishment considering in 2012 coal contributed to 38% of the energy produced. The last coal mine also closed in 2015, ending a centuries-old industry.
The UK is a leading figure in the global coal phase-out, which is vital if the United Nation’s aim of restricting the rise in temperature to below 1.5 degrees is going to be possible. Indeed, the government has brought forward its coal cut-off date by one year to October 2024.
This all sounds like major progress in eradicating coal from our energy sector. However, during those coal-free periods, natural gas, another harmful greenhouse gas, made up 33% of electricity production. That was narrowly less than renewable sources which contributed 36%, with nuclear attributed to 21%.
Additionally, coal has partially been replaced by biomass fuels, including the burning of wood pellets which some argue are worse polluters than coal itself. Biomass wood pellets are considered a low carbon alternative and ‘renewable’ because emissions can be offset by planting more trees. But according to the Rachel Carson Council report titled ‘Clear-Cut’, switching from coal to biomass allows governments to meet international targets but fails to create a greener energy system or real environmental change.
The demand for wood pellets, particularly in Europe, now means that trees are being cut down faster than their replacements can grow. Plus, it is more mature trees that have the best carbon-storing and oxygen-producing capabilities. Deforestation also creates other environmental damages such as loss of biodiversity. The UK is importing a huge amount of wood pellets from Eastern Europe as well as the US and Brazil, and this transportation adds to harmful emissions. The largest producer of wood pellets, a US private sector corporation called Enviva, is responsible for the destruction of 50 acres of woodland every day. Furthermore, their production releases environmentally harmful Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) and particles into the air which are damaging to communities near the factories.
Clearly, biomass wood pellets are not a sustainable energy solution in the face of the climate crisis. However, the UK’s consumption of them has increased as fast as its use of coal decreased. This raises questions of whether western governments are serious about going green, or if they simply pay lip service whilst continuing to use harmful means of energy production, rather than fully funding truly renewable energy.