Are all green electricity tariffs equal?

A large electrical pylon standing in a scenic landscape with mountains partially covered in fog, symbolizing the generation of green electricity.

Share

X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Email

The UK’s electricity is generated from a mixture of gas, nuclear fuel, and renewables. In 2023 wind power contributed 29.4%, biomass (organic materials such as wood and animal waste) contributed 5%, solar power contributed 4.9% and hydropower and tidal energy contributed 1.8% (source: National Grid).

That is a total of 41%, a significant improvement on the 2% from renewable sources achieved in 1991, and the largest source of electricity supplied to the grid.

Table of Contents

What is a green electricity tariff?

If you buy green electricity from your supplier, they must ensure that they can evidence sufficient green electricity generation to meet your (and their other customers on a green electricity tariff) needs. This is sometimes referred to as ‘matching.’

What it does not do is change the fuel mix of the energy you consume; like everyone else using the grid your electricity will still come from a mixture of renewables, natural gas, nuclear, coal and other fuels.

Green energy generation for tariffs

There are three different methods energy suppliers can evidence green electricity generation to support their green electricity tariffs. They are:

Purchasing REGOs (Renewable Certificates of Origin) from a generator of renewable electricity.

REGOs are earned for every MWh (megawatt hour) of electricity generated. The existence of REGOs mean that the generator can sell the electricity they generate to one customer and the Certificate to another.

With prices relatively low – £8.75 per MWh in November 2022 and £20 in October 2023 (source: Energy UK) they are the cheapest way for energy suppliers to match a green electricity tariff.

Investing in renewable energy

Investing in this can be by building their own renewable energy plant, such as a solar farm. This might be in partnership with one or more other investors.

Contracting directly with a renewable energy producer

This can be when they purchase the renewable energy they generate under what is known as a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA).

Energy suppliers may use more than one of these methods when developing their green electricity tariffs.

What are the pros and cons of each method?

The main issue with an energy supplier purchasing REGOs, is additionality. In other words, is the purchase of green electricity backed by REGO’s creating any additional supply of renewable electricity?

The most likely answer to this question is no, given the low value of REGOs and the uncertainty the generator faces over income from the sale of REGO’s (for which historically, there has been low demand).

Tighter green energy regulations

With regulations being introduced and higher demand (leading to higher prices) this could start to change in future.

The pro for REGO route, is that tariffs based on them are likely to be the same or only cost a little more than a regular tariff.

This is also a con for the investing and contracting route, as the consumer will be helping to fund the investment being made by the supplier.

The investment route is the obvious winner in terms of additionality. The supplier is making a direct investments in renewable energy plant that it owns and controls.

The contracting route may also result in additionality, as the PPA gives the producer greater certainty over future income and with it the opportunity to invest.

Solar panels on red brick homes under a clear blue sky, representing the concept of green electricity tariffs.

Which green energy supplier should I chose?

Which? have produced a handy guide to the differences between green energy suppliers with a ranked table of energy suppliers.

The top scoring suppliers are:

  • Good Energy
  • Octopus
  • 100 Green
  • Ecotricity 

These green energy suppliers all scored highly for generating renewable power.

Green energy generation

These suppliers were also the top four in the Ethical Consumers score table of Ethical Energy Suppliers, although to see the whole table it is necessary to be a subscriber.

Understanding their renewable energy investment

If doing your own research, the supplier’s website is the place to go.

If they are investing in renewable energy, it is likely that information on what they are doing can be found there.

Green energy tariffs in the UK: Conclusion

As more of the electricity within the grid comes from renewable sources, so the gap between a business as usual and a green electricity tariff gets smaller.

However, there is still a long way to go before the UK achieves its goal of reaching next zero by 2050.

Supporting renewable energy

If you are concerned about climate change and your budget allows (although there may be little difference in cost) you should opt for a green electricity tariff with a supplier that is investing in new renewable electricity generation and/or contracting to purchase the electricity directly from another company that does through a PPA.

It is only in this way that can you be sure that what you pay your supplier is supporting additional renewable electricity generation.

Sources of Further Information Ethical consumer – Do green energy tariffs make a difference?

Energy Saving Trust – How to switch energy supplier (with a useful section on green electricity tariffs)

Recommended for you

New: Find out more about NEF's Impact

Discover the difference we're making in National Energy Foundation's latest Impact Report. See how we're creating positive change in energy efficiency and sustainability.

National Energy Foundation
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.