Pointless flying? Why were airlines flying empty planes during the pandemic?

Share

X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Email

Mysteriously, hundreds of empty flights are leaving and entering the UK each month for seemingly no purpose. Dubbed “Ghost Flights”, and loosely defined as flights containing under 10% of passenger capacity, the reason behind this phenomenon remains unclear. Between March 2020 and September 2021, an estimated 15,000 virtually empty flights departed from the UK to international destinations. Airlines release little to no information on these flights, such as statistics on their frequency and reasons for their departure. Climate activists are calling for both more transparency on these flights, and also changes to the systems in place that cause them to happen in the first place.

Normally, these ghost flights travel because of a “slot system” which is in place in all major UK airports. This system essentially operates under a “use it or lose it” principle, meaning if the airlines don’t fly planes for at least 80% of their allotted times, the slots will become available for purchase by other companies. The slot system has always been controversial; it seems to be more popular with high budget airlines, who think it encourages competition. Meanwhile a spokesperson for Ryanair complained that the system leaves fewer slots available for budget airlines. This scheme is supposedly designed to prevent excessive flight cancellations but has instead resulted in airlines sending empty flights to avoid losing slots.

The aviation industry was one of the hardest hit by the COVID-19 pandemic, suffering a 97% reduction in air travel in the year 2020. Initially, slot rules were suspended only on flights from countries with the highest number of cases, since so few flights were operating on these routes. From March 2020, the 80% slot rule was completely suspended, allowing airlines to adjust their schedules according to the severe decline in demand. As the pandemic eased, and air travel slowly resumed, the slot rule was incrementally increased. Currently, the UK government has set the minimum threshold at 70%, which is higher than the EU threshold of 64%.

The real mystery is why so many “ghost flights” were still operating during the pandemic, when the slot system was supposedly suspended. This question remains essentially unanswered, despite investigation by multiple newspapers. Some theories suggest it may have been due to planes needing to be moved around, while others suggest they were being used as freight transport.

These “ghost flights” have sparked anger from the public, owing to the huge amount of emissions they represent. Aviation uses kerosene, which is a fossil fuel, making flying the most carbon intensive form of travel by a significant margin. This is particularly relevant to the UK, where aviation is much more prevalent, and makes up about 10% of CO2 emissions (compared to 2% globally).

Aircraft are one of the hardest technologies to make renewable, because of the high specificity of fuel requirements. Currently, the only feasible avenue is improving efficiency of aircraft, so they are consuming less fuel per mile travelled. While some electrical aircraft prototypes exist, they seem unfeasible for long haul journeys. Some climate activists and academics are suggesting we should be gradually closing airports and reducing flight travel until electrical planes become a feasible option. Others argue that carbon capturing technologies may be the answer, since they are likely to be developed more quickly. Other options include the development of suitable biofuels, that could either supplement or replace the kerosene. Changes to the slot system and a ban on “ghost flights” would have significant positive effect on emissions figures, and is a simple first step that could be made by the aviation industry. This has therefore been a point of focus for many climate activists, with a petition currently being proposed to end “ghost flights”. You can find it here.

Excessive flying is having a devastating effect on the environment, with the UK being one of the biggest culprits. Going forward, airports and airlines need to be more transparent with the public on all types of flight and emissions data, particularly regarding ghost flights which still remain a mystery for the most part.

References:

  • https://houseofcommons.shorthandstories.com/coronavirus-impact-aviation-transport-report/index.html

 

 

 

  • https://www.theguardian.com/news/audio/2022/mar/07/the-scandal-of-britains-ghost-flights-podcast

 

Recommended for you

New: Find out more about NEF's Impact

Discover the difference we're making in National Energy Foundation's latest Impact Report. See how we're creating positive change in energy efficiency and sustainability.

National Energy Foundation
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.