When should I buy an Electric Vehicle?

Share

X
Facebook
LinkedIn
Email

Electric cars were once a rare sight, and even rarer sound, on UK roads, but as the 2020s progress they are growing increasingly popular. 14% of new cars registered this year are Electric vehicles (EVs) up from 8% in 2020, whilst a survey of drivers shows 50% of UK respondents have seen their attitudes to EVs become more positive over the past 3 years. 

The climate crisis, and the awareness of how petrol and diesel cars contribute to it, is a clear driver for this shift – the same survey shows lower CO2 emissions are the main reason that drivers would consider switching to an EV.  Fully electric vehicles produce zero-emissions at the tail-pipe, whereas SUVs (another popular and far more environmentally damaging car segment) can produce as much as half a kilo of CO2 every mile.   

As always with the environment, however, there are far more complexities to consider when making the best choice. Notwithstanding active travel and public transport always being better for the environment, when comparing private vehicles we should take the entire life-cycle impact of the car into account. Focusing on EVs’ carbon emissions gives three additional areas to think about: 

  1. Car and battery production
  2. Carbon content of the electricity used for charging 
  3. Impact of battery recycling 

The embedded carbon from producing batteries can represent as much as 30-40% of an EV’s lifetime carbon emissions. This sunk cost would represent all of an EV’s lifetime emissions at purchase and means EVs can take several years of operation to outperform the average carbon emissions of combustion engine vehicles (ICEV).  

Therefore, when is switching to an EV the best option environmentally?  

Comparing EVs and ICEVs 

When judging the sustainability of switching to an EV, the first consideration should be your existing ICEV. Since the embedded carbon of the ICEV is already paid as a sunk cost, the correct comparison is against the average operating carbon costs. The Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology has created the helpful climobil app to compare vehicles’ environmental impact. This shows that the most popular model in the UK, the Ford Fiesta, has total operating carbon costs of 163g CO2 per km driven (of which 99g is emitted at the tailpipe), or 1,700kg in a year with average mileage. Larger models see higher costs, with 2,225kg of annual carbon for the Nissan Qashqai and the Land Rover Defender on 4550kg. 

These figures are contrasted in the chart below with the annual average carbon cost of the UK’s most popular EV, the Tesla Model 3. This shows how the average annual carbon impact of a Model 3 bought in 2021 drops the longer it is owned. Here, there are two main effects lowering carbon over time: 

  1. Spreading the sunk costs – the embedded carbon in production, particularly for the battery, are averaged out over more years.
  2. More renewables in the UK energy grid – as fossil fuels are phased out and more renewable electricity generation brought on-grid, the carbon cost of refuelling is reduced (1).

The chart shows that the EV would outperform the carbon intensive Land Rover in just 3 years, a Nissan Qashqai in 6 years, and the Ford Fiesta in 9 years. Whilst there is some benefit from a cleaner electricity grid, the main factor that affects the carbon intensity of an EV is how long it is used (and therefore how long the production of a new EV is avoided). 

Effect of future improvements 

It’s likely that the future carbon cost of EVs will continue to drop as technology advances. A greener electricity grid in the country of manufacture will bring down the carbon costs in production. Research by BloombergNEF also indicates that new battery chemistries are progressing faster than expected. This technology will increase durability and energy density, which would allow for longer battery lifespans and efficiency improvements.  

The ICCT estimates that these two developments alongside better recycling of lithium can drastically reduce EVs’ embedded carbon by as much as 50%. The second figure shows how the carbon cost of a new Tesla drops depending on purchase year. Assuming that the new EV is kept for 8 years, each year going forward sees lower lifetime carbon costs as the UK grid becomes greener and production costs fall.

Therefore, it’s best to switch to an EV right away if a) your current vehicle is highly polluting (150g CO2 per km or more) or b) you can commit to keeping the new EV for a long time (8 years or longer). In other cases, it may actually make more sense to keep an efficient ICEV running and switch to an EV as technology advances later this decade.  

The sustainable choice is to switch to an EV, but don’t worry too much about when.  

(1)  Planned electricity generation by the Department of Business Energy and Industrial Strategy would see the average carbon intensity of the UK grid fall from 196 g CO2 per kWh in 2021 to 162g in 2030. 

Recommended for you

New: Find out more about NEF's Impact

Discover the difference we're making in National Energy Foundation's latest Impact Report. See how we're creating positive change in energy efficiency and sustainability.

National Energy Foundation
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.